How Do You Keep Homemade Dog Treats Fresh? (Solved & Explained!)

How you keep homemade dog treats fresh will depend on several factors. In general though, meatless dry treats can go into an airtight container at room for about two to three weeks. Soft or moist treats, especially ones with meat, can go into the refrigerator for seven to 10 days.

The ingredients of the dog treats will be a major component in your choice of storage. Other things include the texture, softness and size of the treats as well as your immediate location, your storage method and after-baking cooling time.

Where Should You Store Homemade Dog Treats?

The best place to store most homemade dog treats is in the refrigerator. But, if you want long-term storage options, you can put them in the freezer. Vacuum sealed bags are ideal to keep them good for up to a year. You could also store unbaked dough in the freezer for later preparation. If you do this, ensure you double wrap it to protect the dough from freezer burn.

How Does the Ingredients Affect Keeping Homemade Dog Treats Fresh?

The ingredients comprising the dog treats will have everything to do with their storage and the length of time they will stay fresh. Typically, moist or wet dog treats will have a shorter shelf life than dry ones.

Veggie and/or Fruit Treats

Fruit and veggie treats tend to stay soft, even after baking with the intention of making them crispy. This means they’ll have a shorter lifespan. However, you can put these into an airtight container and keep them in the refrigerator for about a week to 10 days.

Alternatively, you can loosely secure them in plastic wrap or sandwich bags along with something like cheesecloth. This will prevent the treats from getting too soggy.

Wheat Flour versus Gluten-Free Flour

While dogs shouldn’t eat wheat flour, treats made with it do tend to keep for a longer period of time than ones made with gluten-free flour. However, gluten-free flour does make treats a little softer. But, the type of gluten-free flour will determine this.

For instance, all-purpose and oat flour will keep for longer than garbanzo or almond. Storing these in a sealed jar in the fridge for about a week will suffice. However, you want to check them periodically to ensure they aren’t going bad during their storage time.

Meat & Fish Treats

Any kind of treat made with meat, fish or broth can go into an airtight container in the fridge. These will last for a week at most.

Can You Use Natural Preservatives in the Dog Treat Recipe To Extend Freshness?

There are many natural preservatives you can use to ensure your homemade dog treats keep for a little longer. Things like honey, rosemary, vitamin E and vitamin C will extend the shelf life by about three to five days. 

If you’re making dog treats with the intention of selling them to the public, you can also get mold inhibitors. These are good for gummy and moist treats. You just want to ensure that it contains natural and healthy ingredients.

How Does the Type & Size Affect Keeping Homemade Dog Treats Fresh?

Of course the type and size of the homemade dog treats will affect how long they will stay fresh. Tiny kibble-sized treats will not last as long as ones that are the size of normal bone-shaped biscuits. However, the drier and crunchier the treat, the longer it will keep.

How Does Your Location Affect the Freshness of Homemade Dog Treats?

While it isn’t terribly important, where you live can affect how you store homemade dog treats. This is particularly true during the shifting temperatures of the seasons. For instance, if you live in a hot climate and you don’t have a good air conditioner, you will have to keep your counter-stored treats in the fridge. This is because the hotter weather will cause the treats to spoil faster.

This means that unless you can maintain the general temperature and humidity throughout your home, it’s always best to find a way to store the treats in the fridge.

Should You Defrost Frozen Treats Before Letting a Dog Eat Them?

You don’t always have to defrost frozen treats before letting your dog eat them. This is particularly true of treats intended as frozen. However, smaller and crunchier treats will be better frozen whereas big or thicker treats should defrost for a little bit.

How Should You Bake Dog Treats to Extend Their Lifespan?

In the event you want treats that will last for a little longer than a week, make them crunchy by drying them out toward the end of the baking period. Simply turn off the oven and open the door a smidge. Let them sit there for about 30 to 45 minutes. This will crisp them up.

Another method is when the baking period finishes, turn your oven down to a lower temperature. For instance, if your recipe calls for the treats to bake at 375°F, turn the oven down to 150°F. Continue baking the treats for about 20 to 30 more minutes.

How Long Do Frozen Dog Treats Stay Fresh?

Frozen dog treats, such as yogurt pops, will keep for several months in the freezer. Not only are these ideal for hot summer days but you can offer them as “special” training treats as a super reward for your dog.

How Long Should You Cool Treats after Baking to Ensure They Stay Fresh?

Once you’ve finished baking the dog treats, one of the most essential steps to keeping them as fresh as possible is allowing them to cool. Use a wire cooling rack and let them rest for an hour or two before you put them into a jar, sandwich bag or other similar container.

If there is any amount of warmth in the treats, it will cause condensation to form inside its storage container. This produces a breeding ground for bacteria, mold and making the treats inedible.