Note: If you click some of the links in this article we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.
Spread the love
Many dog owners who make homemade meals for their pets love adding sardines for the omega-3 benefits, but recent concerns about arsenic contamination have left them wondering if these tiny fish are actually safe. You might have seen alarming headlines or social media posts claiming that sardines contain dangerous levels of arsenic that could harm your dog.
The good news is that sardines are generally safe for dogs when fed in moderation, and the arsenic levels found in most sardines are well below dangerous thresholds for canine consumption. However, understanding the facts about arsenic in fish and knowing how to feed sardines safely can help you make the best choices for your pet’s health.
This guide will break down the science behind arsenic in sardines, separate fact from fiction about detox myths, and give you practical guidelines for safely feeding sardines to your dog. You’ll learn exactly what to watch for and when you might need to be concerned about your dog’s fish consumption.
Dog owners choose sardines for their pets because of impressive nutritional benefits and practical advantages. These small fish pack powerful health benefits while remaining budget-friendly and easy to serve.
Health Benefits Like Omega-3s, Protein, Vitamins, And Minerals
Sardines deliver exceptional nutritional value for your dog’s health. They’re packed with protein, omega-3 fatty acids, and vitamins B12 and D that support your pet’s overall wellness.
The omega-3 fatty acids in sardines provide multiple health benefits. These essential fats help reduce inflammation in your dog’s body. They also improve skin and coat health, making your dog’s fur shinier and healthier.
Your dog gets high-quality protein from sardines. This protein helps build and repair tissues throughout your pet’s body. It supports muscle development and maintains healthy organ function.
Key vitamins and minerals in sardines include:
Vitamin B12 for nervous system health
Vitamin D for bone strength
Calcium for teeth and bones
Phosphorus for energy metabolism
Convenience And Affordability
Sardines offer practical benefits that make them appealing to busy pet owners. Canned sardines are readily available at most grocery stores year-round. You don’t need to visit specialty pet stores or order online.
The cost factor makes sardines attractive for many dog owners. They’re much less expensive than premium dog treats or supplements. A single can of sardines can provide multiple servings for your dog.
Storage is simple with canned sardines. They have long shelf lives and don’t require refrigeration until opened. You can stock up when they’re on sale without worrying about spoilage.
Preparation time is minimal with sardines. You simply open the can and serve appropriate portions. No cooking or complex preparation is needed.
Typical Feeding Routines And Portion Sizes
While many pet owners use sardines as treats or meal toppers, more and more are using canned sardines in water as a regular protein source in homemade diets. Feeding sardines several times a week, or even daily as part of a balanced rotation with other proteins, is common—especially for those looking for a safer, portable alternative to raw meat.
Recommended serving sizes by dog weight:
Dog Size
Weight Range
Sardine Portion
Small
Under 20 lbs
1/2 can
Medium
20-50 lbs
1 can
Large
50+ lbs
1.5 – 2 cans
Many owners add sardines as meal toppers or mixed with kibble and fresh greens and fruit. You can mash sardines into your dog’s regular food or serve them as standalone treats. Some dogs prefer whole sardines while others like them chopped up.
Start with smaller portions when introducing sardines. Gradually increase the amount over time as your dog’s digestive system adjusts. Watch for any signs of stomach upset during the transition period.
The Arsenic Scare—Where Did It Start?
The sudden concern about arsenic in sardines began with a podcast story and spread quickly through social media. A medical case study from 2018 added scientific weight to these worries, making pet owners question whether sardines are safe for their dogs.
Joe Rogan’s Story And The Critical MAS Article
Joe Rogan shared his experience on his podcast about getting arsenic poisoning from eating too many sardines. He mentioned eating three tins of sardines nightly and developing symptoms that led to elevated arsenic levels in his blood.
The story gained more credibility when people discovered a 2018 medical case study. This study documented arsenic poisoning in a 45-year-old man who ate large amounts of canned sardines regularly.
The patient experienced headaches and nerve problems for months. His urine showed arsenic levels of 22+ ug/L, which is above the normal range of less than 15 ug/L.
Key symptoms included:
Chronic headaches
Numbness in hands and feet
Hand tremors
Light and noise sensitivity
The medical report confirmed that heavy sardine consumption was the likely cause of his arsenic exposure.
Why Pet Owners Are Suddenly Worried
You likely started questioning sardines because dogs are much smaller than humans. If a 45-year-old man got arsenic poisoning from sardines, what could happen to your 20-pound dog?
Pet owners began calculating dosages based on body weight. A small dog eating one sardine might consume proportionally more arsenic than a human eating several tins.
Common concerns include:
Dogs eat sardines more frequently as treats
Smaller body weight means faster toxin buildup
Dogs can’t report early symptoms like headaches
The timing also matters. More people started feeding their dogs sardines during the recent push toward fresh, whole food diets for pets.
Social media groups for natural pet feeding amplified these worries. Members shared the human case study and warned others about potential risks to their dogs.
What Is Arsenic And Why Is It In Sardines?
Arsenic exists in two main forms with different safety levels. Ocean waters naturally contain arsenic that fish absorb throughout their lives.
Difference Between Organic And Inorganic Arsenic
Organic arsenic is the type found in seafood like sardines. This form is much less harmful to your body than its counterpart.
Your body processes these two types very differently. Organic arsenic passes through your system more easily. Inorganic arsenic stays in your body longer and causes more health problems.
The organic form in fish doesn’t build up in your tissues like the inorganic type does. This makes sardines safer than foods with inorganic arsenic contamination.
How Arsenic Gets Into Seafood
Arsenic occurs naturally in ocean water and sediments. Fish absorb it through their gills and by eating smaller sea creatures.
Sardines are filter feeders that eat tiny organisms in the water. This feeding method means they pick up more arsenic than some other fish types.
Water pollution can make arsenic levels higher in some areas. Fish caught near industrial sites may contain more arsenic than those from cleaner waters.
Typical Levels Found In Sardines
Most sardines contain arsenic levels that fall within safety limits set by health agencies. The exact amount varies based on where the fish were caught.
Arsenic levels found in sardines are typically well within the safety limits established by health authorities. Different brands may have different levels.
Testing shows most canned sardines have trace amounts rather than dangerous levels. The processing and canning don’t add extra arsenic to the fish.
Larger fish that live longer tend to have higher arsenic levels. Sardines are smaller and younger, which keeps their arsenic content lower.
Is Arsenic In Sardines Dangerous For Dogs?
Arsenic in sardines poses minimal risk to dogs when fed in normal amounts. The levels found in sardines are typically well below toxic thresholds, and most dogs would need to consume extremely large quantities over extended periods to experience poisoning.
What Science Says About Arsenic Toxicity In Dogs
The FDA sets the maximum tolerated arsenic level for dogs at 12.5mg/kg of body weight. This means a 50-pound dog would need to consume over 280mg of arsenic to reach toxic levels.
Research shows that sardines contain much lower arsenic levels compared to other seafood. Sardines have less arsenic than shrimp, tuna, and scallops, making them a safer fish choice for your dog.
The type of arsenic matters too. Inorganic arsenic is more dangerous than organic arsenic found naturally in fish. Most arsenic in sardines is the organic form, which your dog’s body processes and eliminates more easily.
Key toxicity factors:
Body weight – Larger dogs can tolerate more
Duration of exposure – Long-term consumption is riskier
A typical 3.75-ounce can of sardines contains roughly 0.1-0.3mg of total arsenic. If you give your 30-pound dog half a can twice weekly, they consume about 0.1-0.3mg of arsenic per week.
Weekly exposure example:
30-pound dog eating 2 servings of sardines
Total arsenic intake: ~0.2mg per week
Safe threshold: Over 150mg would be needed for toxicity
Safety margin: 750 times below toxic levels
Symptoms Of Arsenic Poisoning In Dogs
Arsenic poisoning in dogs causes specific symptoms that develop over time. Acute poisoning from large amounts shows up within hours, while chronic exposure creates gradual health problems.
Early warning signs include:
Vomiting and diarrhea
Loss of appetite
Excessive drooling
Abdominal pain
Advanced symptoms involve:
Weakness and lethargy
Difficulty walking
Tremors or seizures
Dark, tarry stools
Chronic arsenic exposure can damage your dog’s liver, kidneys, and nervous system. You might notice skin problems, hair loss, or behavioral changes over weeks or months.
The good news is that these symptoms only appear with massive arsenic intake. The small amounts in sardines won’t cause these problems when fed appropriately.
Actual Risk With Moderate Sardine Use
Your dog faces virtually no arsenic risk from eating sardines in moderation. The arsenic levels in sardines fall well within safety limits established by health authorities.
To put this in perspective, your dog would need to eat dozens of cans of sardines daily for weeks to approach toxic arsenic levels. This amount would cause other health problems long before arsenic poisoning occurs.
Real-world safety factors:
Normal feeding provides 1/1000th of toxic levels
Other health issues would appear first from overfeeding
The biggest risks come from feeding sardines packed in salt, oil, or seasonings rather than from arsenic content. Choose plain sardines and stick to recommended portions for the safest approach.
Why Rotating Proteins Is Important
Protein rotation prevents your dog from developing food sensitivities and ensures balanced nutrition. Sardines alone cannot meet all of your dog’s nutritional needs.
Different protein sources provide different amino acid profiles. Fish, chicken, beef, and lamb each offer unique nutritional benefits that support your dog’s health.
Benefits of Protein Rotation:
Reduces risk of food allergies
Provides complete amino acid profiles
Prevents nutritional deficiencies
Minimizes toxin exposure from single sources
Sardines lack essential nutrients like calcium and phosphorus that your dog needs. They should supplement, not replace, your dog’s regular balanced diet.
Rotating between sardines, other fish, and land-based proteins gives your dog the most complete nutrition. This approach also keeps mealtime interesting and prevents your dog from becoming picky about food.
What Should You Do If You’re Worried?
If you think your dog might have arsenic poisoning from eating too many sardines, watch for specific symptoms and know when to get help. Quick action and the right tests can protect your pet’s health.
Signs To Watch For In Your Dog
Watch your dog closely for neurological symptoms. Arsenic poisoning often causes tingling and numbness in the legs and paws first.
Your dog might walk differently or seem unsteady. They could drag their back feet or have trouble jumping up on furniture.
Look for these warning signs:
Weakness in back legs
Trembling or shaking
Loss of coordination
Difficulty standing up
Strange walking patterns
Digestive problems can also occur. Your dog might have diarrhea, vomiting, or lose their appetite completely.
Some dogs get headaches from arsenic poisoning. They might press their head against walls or furniture. Your dog could also seem confused or act differently than normal.
Skin changes happen in severe cases. Look for darkening around the nose, paw pads, or belly area.
Call your vet right away if you see any of these symptoms. Heavy consumption of canned sardines has caused arsenic poisoning in people, so dogs face similar risks.
When And How To Test For Arsenic
Stop feeding sardines to your dog for at least 3-5 days before testing. Arsenic from seafood can show up in tests even when it’s not harmful.
Your vet will likely order a urine test first. This shows recent arsenic exposure from the past few days.
Blood tests work for very recent exposure. Hair and nail tests show longer-term exposure over several months.
Ask your vet specifically about inorganic arsenic levels. This is the dangerous type that causes health problems.
Normal arsenic levels in urine should be under 15 micrograms per liter. Anything above 20 micrograms per liter needs attention.
Keep a food diary for your dog. Write down exactly which sardine brands you used and how much you fed daily.
Take photos of the sardine cans or packages. Your vet might want to know the specific brands and where they came from.
Some vets might want to test multiple times. Arsenic levels can change quickly after you stop feeding sardines.
Steps To Take If You’ve Been Feeding A Lot Of Sardines
Stop feeding sardines immediately if you’re worried about arsenic. Switch to other protein sources like chicken, beef, or commercial dog food.
Remove all sardines from your dog’s diet. Don’t give them as treats or mix them with other foods.
Focus on a diverse range of food sources instead of relying on one type of fish.
Call your vet and explain exactly how much your dog has been eating. Be honest about the amounts and how long you’ve been feeding sardines.
Keep detailed records of your dog’s symptoms. Write down when they started and if they’re getting worse or better.
Increase your dog’s water intake if possible. This helps flush toxins from their system naturally.
Don’t try to make your dog vomit unless your vet tells you to. Arsenic poisoning needs professional treatment.
Watch your dog closely for the next few weeks. Some arsenic symptoms can take time to appear or get worse.
If tests show high arsenic levels, your vet might prescribe special treatments. Follow all instructions exactly and keep all follow-up appointments.
Arsenic “Detox” Myths—What Works And What Doesn’t
Many pet owners worry about arsenic and turn to popular “detox” methods they find online. Most of these supposed remedies don’t actually remove arsenic from your dog’s body, and some can even be harmful.
Common Detox Myths Like Cilantro, Garlic, Chlorella
You’ve probably seen claims that cilantro can pull heavy metals from your dog’s system. This myth comes from a single study done in test tubes, not living animals. Cilantro doesn’t actually remove arsenic from blood or organs.
Garlic is even more problematic. Some websites claim it helps detox dogs, but garlic is toxic to dogs. It damages their red blood cells and can cause anemia. Never give your dog garlic for any reason.
Chlorella supplements are marketed as arsenic removers. While this green algae has some health benefits, there’s no solid proof it removes arsenic from dogs. Some chlorella products may even contain heavy metals themselves.
Other popular myths include:
Activated charcoal – Only works for recent poisoning, not long-term detox
Bentonite clay – No evidence for arsenic removal in dogs
Special detox diets – Usually just expensive marketing
What The Science Actually Says
Real research shows your dog’s body already has a natural detox system through the liver, kidneys and lungs. These organs work together to filter out toxins without special supplements.
Studies on arsenic removal focus on medical treatments for severe poisoning. These treatments require veterinary supervision and aren’t needed for normal dietary exposure.
The liver does most of the work. It changes arsenic into forms the body can eliminate through urine. Foods like broccoli and kale contain compounds that support liver function, but they don’t actively pull arsenic out.
No supplement has been proven to safely remove arsenic from healthy dogs. The few treatments that work for severe arsenic poisoning can only be given by vets in emergency situations.
The Best Way To Lower Risk Is Moderation And Variety
The most effective approach is preventing too much arsenic exposure in the first place. This means being smart about what you feed your dog regularly.
Rotate your protein sources. Don’t feed sardines or any single food every day. Mix in chicken, beef, lamb, and other proteins throughout the week.
Feed sardines 2-3 times per week maximum. This gives your dog the omega-3 benefits without overloading them with arsenic. Smaller portions work just as well as large ones.
Choose variety in everything. Different foods have different contaminant levels. Avoiding foods high in arsenic while rotating your dog’s diet naturally lowers their total exposure.
Support your dog’s natural detox organs with:
Fresh water daily – helps kidneys flush toxins
Regular exercise – improves circulation and organ function
Healthy weight – reduces stress on liver and kidneys
Sardine Safety Tips For Pet Owners
Smart sardine selection and proper preparation help protect your dog from contamination while maximizing nutritional benefits. Following storage guidelines and rotating proteins reduces exposure risks.
How To Pick Safe Sardines (Brands, Origins, Packaging)
Choose sardines packed in water instead of oil or sauce. Oil adds unnecessary calories and some sauces contain garlic or onions that are toxic to dogs.
My name is Danny Jackson and I’m the CEO and Chief Editor behind Petloverguy.com. After spending a decade working with vets and private clients as an animal behavioral and nutritional specialist I co-founded Pet Lover Guy to help other pet parents learn how to interact with, and make the most of the time that they spend with their adopted and rescued best pet friends.
Working with Ella, our chihuahua rescue, we seek to help all dog and cat lovers have the happiest life possible.
