Should I Use a Harness or Collar? (Solved & Explained!)

Harnesses are safer than collars. They distribute tension around the neck and chest by completely embracing your dog’s body. 

Your dog may tug while walking or may want to run suddenly when he sees any external stimulus. In such cases, using a harness gives your dog flexibility of movement and prevents injury.

Since Collars are on your dog’s neck, they can be easily shaken off. If you are walking your dog in an area open to traffic, you may encounter dangerous situations.

What Are The Pros Of Harnesses?

Harnesses are very flexible and useful thanks to their adjustable width. Your dog can run and play as he wishes with the harness firmly in place.

Harnesses are compatible with any time of leash. If you use an extendable leash your dog can walk long distances under your control.

Harnesses are very comfortable compared to collars. They don’t hurt their neck or chest and give your dog great flexibility and freedom of movement without injury.

Harnesses are a very good choice for dog owners. They distribute pressure across the chest which is less prone to injury than the neck.

Dogs are always alert to external stimuli such as cats, birds, and squirrels, and they tend to lunge towards these things, which creates pressure in the neck or strangulation if they are wearing a normal collar. 

Thanks to the harness you use, you can keep them safer and ensure that they do not accidentally hurt themselves while tugging.

What Are The Cons Of Harnesses?

Although harnesses are safer, they can be uncomfortable for some large breed dogs if you are not careful about the size and fit of the harness.

In addition, one of the disadvantages of the harnesses is that there is no tag place for your dog’s identity, and they should be removed after a walk, meaning that if your dog gets out they cannot be identified quickly.

Apart from that, harnesses are bulkier and heavier than collars and tend to be more expensive.

Harnesses are a little more complicated to put on, and many must be put on over the head, which many dogs do not like.

If your dog does not want to wear a harness, you may need to give them some time to get used to it. They will get used to it after wearing the harness a couple of times.

When Should You Use A Harness?

Harnesses are suitable for most dogs, and they come in many shapes and sizes. Harnesses are especially recommended for dogs who experience the following:

If Your Dog is a Brachycephalic Breed

Since brachycephalic dogs, such as Pugs and French Bulldogs, have flat noses and some respiratory problems as a result. 

Neck collars prevent them from breathing comfortably and make the situation worse. For this reason, harnesses are more suitable for dogs for experience this condition.

If Your Dog Has a History of Tracheal Collapse

Tracheal collapse is a health problem that causes difficulty in breathing and respiration. Collars are not suitable for dogs with this type of issue due to the pressure they put on the throat, which constricts the trachea further.

If You Have a Breed with Risk Factors for Spinal Problems

Support harnesses are recommended for some long-bodied dogs and dogs with intervertebral disc problems. These dogs cannot walk comfortably without harnesses, and the extra support makes any form of exercise easier.

If Your Dog Has a History or Risk of Orthopedic Disease

Dogs with any orthopedic problems may be better supported by a harness than a collar. Harnesses are great for dogs that experience hip dysplasia, arthritis, spinal injuries or senior dogs with weakened bones or joints.

What Are The Pros of Collars?

Collars are much easier and more practical in terms of use. Collars can stay on your dog’s neck all the time both in and out of the house without bothering your dog too much.

In addition, when you are going to take your dog for a walk, putting on a collar is much easier than putting on a harness.

Some dogs do not take off their collar during the day, and they get used to it, meaning you only have to attach the leash before you head out. Because of this practicality and convenience, many dog owners prefer collars for their dogs. 

There are also identification tags on the collars. In this way, even if your dog is lost, if a neighbor finds them they can easily bring them back to you instead of going to the vet to identify the chip.

This makes them more secure. Collars are more common for large breed dogs. But some large breed dogs can pull on their collars too hard. In such cases, it may be better to get a harness.

What Are The Cons of Collars?

Collars may not be suitable for dogs with certain health problems. They are not recommended for dogs with glaucoma, proptose, and neck problems. 

Collars can be harmful, especially for dogs that pull. If your dog has such problems, you should use a harness instead of a collar. 

Collars are not safe for dogs that pull. Dogs that pull can hurt themselves when wearing collars, and the owner has less control and is less able to constrain them.

In addition, collars can come off the neck easily. This can be very dangerous, especially if you are walking with your dog in a trafficked area. 

When collars are put on dogs, they put pressure on the neck and trachea. If you pull your dog excessively, you will restrict his breathing and your dog may choke.

Do Collars Hurt My Dog’s Neck?

Collars generally do not hurt dogs, but there are exceptions. Because some dog breeds can be very excited abnd hyperactive when they go outside, and inadvertently hurt themselves by pulling.

Dogs like this are better suited to harnesses. Harnesses offer width and length adjustment, so you can tailor it to the size you want and make your dog more comfortable.