Is Purina or Pedigree Better? (Solved & Explained!)

With the exception of price and possibly for weight loss, Purina is easily the winner when both dog foods are compared. The first consideration is the protein sources. Pedigree uses quite a lot of plant-based proteins with a minimal amount of poultry and other animal meat by-products for its protein base.

Purina foods are usually higher in protein and fats that your dog needs, but not always – the problem lies in that both foods offer a number of specific formulas. For instance, Purina One has 30% protein, while Pedigree’s ‘high protein’ kibble is at about 27%.

Pedigree also has ‘adult dry dog food’, which is at 21% protein—much lower than expected. Overall, with the exception of their ‘high protein’ kibble, Purina almost always wins in the protein and fats category.

Fiber is your next consideration and if you need more fiber for your dog, Pedigree might well be a good choice, as their plant content (especially the addition of beet pulp) gives them a slight edge on fiber.

That said, proteins are generally the most important factor for your dog foods and with a few exceptions, Purina generally has the lead in this regard.

In today’s article, we’re going to take a look at questions being asked on the web this week by owners just like you – find out what you need to know about Purina vs. Pedigree foods so that you can find the perfect kibble for your beloved pet! Let’s take a look at what people are asking this week!

Is Purina good dog food?

Purina is good stuff, recommended by nutritionists, vets, and with decades of business and science behind it. It’s got good quality meats to boost its protein content and a number of formulas, so that you can purchase food that is optimized for your dog’s stage of life.

It costs a little extra, but it’s good, quality dog food.

Is Pedigree good dog food?

Pedigree has been in business since 1957 and while it’s considered to be on the ‘low end’ of the dog food spectrum, it is designed to be inexpensive and it’s still quite nourishing for your dog.

The chief complaint with the product has to do with fillers and heavy use of plant proteins, with some animal by products used for meat content that is certainly present, but not in the amounts that you would find in higher-end brands such as Purina.

Is Pedigree owned by Purina?

No, Pedigree is owned by Mars incorporated, while Purina is owned by Nestlé. Pedigree is not the only food owned by Mars, with some of their top-selling brands being IAMS, Whiskas, Royal Canin, and Banfield, though they have many more foods that they provide worldwide.

What is the biggest difference between Purina and Pedigree?

The most notable difference is that Pedigree relies heavily on plant proteins, while Purina has a higher protein composition based on meat. Purina also has a high fish oil content, as well as a lot of fat and protein that dogs need, and the taste of it generally beats out Pedigree most of the time.

That said, Pedigree is still nutritious and fine for dogs, but the high concentration of plant proteins does make it a little harder to digest. Over time, this might not be a good thing, but you can always get a small bag of Purina to mix in just to add a little more meat to the resulting mixed kibble.

Where does Purina get its ingredients?

With the exception of chicken breast (which is considered a by-product in China), 99% of Purina Chicken content comes from the United States, along with 96% of their grain, and 100% of their soy content. As far as the chicken from China, this is only for some of the treats, while the ‘daily foods’ are made in Missouri USA.

Where does Pedigree get its ingredients?

Pedigree ingredients come from Canada and the United States, although there are also locations in the United Kingdom and other places around the world where Pedigree is also manufactured and sold.

As the company has been around since 1957, this is not  surprising, but if you are purchasing Pedigree then odds are it was made in your area with local ingredients.

Why is Pedigree not recommended?

Pedigree did have a recall with some batches of food which involved high levels of Vitamin D. That said, beyond this, the heavy reliance on plant proteins is not necessarily ideal for your dog, who is better equipped to digest and process meat proteins instead.

It is quite healthy and good as a discount option, many just feel that It’s simply not the best dog food on the market. If your dog likes it, however, they can certainly eat pedigree and they won’t suffer any ill effects.

Is Purina good for dogs?

Yes, Purina is quite good for dogs, and a number of animal nutritionists and vets recommend it for dogs. You can get food that is formulated for your dog at different stages and a little bit of label comparison to determine the nutrition when compared to other brands is usually a satisfying experience.

While there are certainly higher-end dogfoods, Purina has a very good reputation that they have earned over the years, so you can definitely feed it to your dog with confidence.

What is wrong with Purina dog food?

As with every product, there are always caveats, and the chief complaints about Purina have to do with certain ingredients. Artificial food coloring is one, along with their choice of preservatives, and the use of low-quality filler present in many foods in the form of cornmeal, wheat, and soy.

That said, these are going to be present in just about any commercial brand, so ultimately you’ll want to do a little label comparison to ensure that your dog is getting the nutrition that you expect from your favorite brand.

What is wrong with Pedigree dog food?

 The chief complaint with Pedigree is that they use lots of plant proteins, with a minimal amount of meat proteins present in their kibble. This is by design, however, in order to produce a nutritious food at a small cost so that they can pass along the savings.

If this worries you, be sure to shop around a little and compare the protein content of the Pedigree and the competitors that you are considering. You should be able to clearly see which proteins are plant based vs. actual meat proteins and this will help you to make a decision on what you want to feed your dog.