Buying Guides

Best Dog Shock Collar Reviews – Buyers Guide

There are a number of good dog shock collar brands, models and types.

This can make things very time-consuming and confusing to find a collar that is best for your dog.

To make things a little easier, we have put together a buying guide of popular and top rated shock collars in 2018.

Dog shock collars can be used for many purposes concerning behavioral adjustments to your pet such as containing their area of roaming or their ceaseless barking.

However, their use is a very controversial matter as they may cause irreversible harm to your dog, be it physical by leaving burn marks on their necks, or mental and emotional by stressing your dog out and causing aggression.

Some dogs, however, are used for hunting or in a place where they might face dangerous venomous animals such as snakes or bugs, and in this case, a shock collar may seem like a good solution.

It should, by all means, be considered a last resort.

So in case you need to condition your dog not to approach venomous snakes or not take food from outside sources that may cause your pet diseases or even death, here are some of the best dog shock collars you can get.

The Best Dog Shock Collars

1. Garmin Delta XC bundle – Best Shock Collar for Multiple Dogs

The Garmin Delta XC bundle proves very handy as it can be used upon 3 dogs.

Compared to other shock collars on the market, it’s not the most affordable, but when you think about its superior range capacity that reaches half a mile, its price is quite justified.

It gives you 3 correction configurations to address different behaviors that you might want to correct on your dog. It also comes with a tone and vibration feature next to the 18 levels of instant or non-stop stimulation. Although some rivals include a lot more levels.

You don’t have to worry too much about the remote because it comes with great durability. It’s waterproof and its design is very compact as it has just 3 buttons through which you can control the collar.

Pros:

  • Wide range of coverage
  • Comes with a lanyard do avoid misplacement
  • Great customer service from Garmin
  • Compact remote size

Cons:

  • Not the cheapest
  • The levels of stimulation aren’t as many
  • Lack of a Barklimited feature found on other Garmin Models

The Garmin Delta XC bundle is a very good choice if you’re planning to train more than one pet as it can be used on 3 dogs. Its performance is great and the results are satisfactory, but it comes at a relatively high price.

2. Petrainer PET998DRD – Best Dog Training Shock Collar

The PET998DRD seems a good choice that fits just about any dog size. You can put it on a small, medium, or large dog of 15 pounds or larger. It fits neck of lengths between 15 to 22 inches long.

The collar itself is made of quite a durable and adjustable nylon material.

Even though the package includes 1 collar, the remote transmitter that comes with it can control 2 collars in case you want to train two dogs at once.

The receiver on the collar is rubber-covered which makes it water-resistant. It also receives signals from up to 330 yards away.

The PET998DRD comes with 100 levels of vibration, 100 levels of static shock, and a level of standard tone.

It also has automatic standby and memory function features that aid it in saving power.

And apart from training purposes, it has a light mode that helps make your dog visible in dim-lit places so that it’s safer to roam around at night without you having to worry about a car running over it.

The LCD display has a blue backlight so you can easily use it during the night too.

Auto-protect mode keeps your training safe as it doesn’t deliver any shocks after 7 consecutive times.

There is little to no hassle when trying to pair the remote to the collar(s) as the process is quite easy and straightforward.

Pros:

  • 100 stimulation modes
  • Rechargeable collar receiver and remote
  •  Ability to control multiple collars/dogs
  •  Power-saving capabilities

Cons:

  • No lifetime warranty
  •  Lack of visual stimulation

The PET998DRD Petrainer Dog Training Collar is one of the best, most affordable choices you can make.

It fits just about any dog size and has various helpful features. Its warranty goes only as long as 5 years, but that by then, your dog would have probably been well-conditioned.

3. Dogtra ARC Remote – Best Dog Shock Collar with Remote

Even though the Dogtra ARC can be used on two dogs, their sizes must not fall short of 15 pounds and their general reactions can’t be too aggressive to new stimuli.

The Dogtra ARC is very comfortable to wear as it has a slim design. Its remote is also small and easy to carry around.

With this collar, you can deliver stimulation either in instant, one-time shocks or in constant ones with longer durations, based on the circumstances.

You also get a vibration setting that can be used to merely get the dog’s attention.

The levels of stimulation have a wide range that extends up to 127 static correction levels on an easily-handled dial.

A problem with this dial design, however, is that it can easily move without you realizing it, and thereby change the level of stimulation on its own.

The Dogtra ARC is waterproof and has a coverage range of a 3/4 mile. It also charges very quickly, taking only two hours. You can also view the level of stimulation and the battery life on the LCD screen.

Pros:

  • Wide range of stimulation levels
  • LCD screen found on the remote to show you the stimulation level and battery remaining
  • Can be used on two dogs
  • An extremely wide range of coverage
  • Small and inconspicuous remote

Cons:

  • Not suitable for dogs smaller than 15 pounds
  • Transmitter setting could be changed with the turning of the knob unknowingly
  • Turning off the collar can be a confusing task

The Dogtra ARC Remote Training Collar System is one of the most expensive devices on this list, but it’s also the one with the widest coverage range. It could be used for training two dogs at a time.

4. iPets PET619S – The Best Small Dog Shock Collar

The iPets PET619S has pretty much the same features found on the previously-mentioned Petrainer PET998DRD, but at a slightly higher price tag, which is a bit inexplicable. A good reason might be that the iPets PET619S is fit for smaller-sized dogs, that weight as little as 10 pounds. It also fits bigger-sized dogs just as well as it fits collar sizes of up to 25 inches long.

You can use it to control many of your dog’s behaviors such as barking, jumping, bolting, and aggression. Its range extends up to 220 yards. Its battery is rechargeable and allows you to charge both the transmitter and receiver simultaneously. You can also get an additional receiver if you wish to train two dogs at the same time.

The waterproof collar is a nice touch for water-dogs like some breeds of mastiffs or golden retrievers.

The pairing process is easy and seamless, and the conductive plastic contact points make it very safe. The remote is designed to be compact and easily-held.

The buttons are laid out that each button serves a separate function so you can quickly praise the positive behaviors with a beep or condemn bad ones with a vibrate or shock, without having to navigate through menus. The intensity of the shock or vibration is also easily administered by the intensity dial that delivers a range between (0-100) levels of stimulation.

Pros:

  • Customizable levels of stimulation
  • Ability to train two dogs at once
  • Fit for smaller-sized dogs

Cons:

  • Stimulation forms don’t include a light one
  • No lifetime warranty

Compared to the cheaper Petrainer PET998DRD that delivers just about the same features as the iPets PET619S, it wouldn’t make sense to buy the latter.

It would, however, be the better choice in case your dog is smaller in size as it’s fit for dogs that weigh about 10 pounds.

5. The SportDOG FieldTrainer 425 – A Good Shock Collar for Golden Retriever

The SportDOG FieldTrainer 425 comes with a subpar 7-leveled stimulation that ranges from low to medium. It suits dogs that weigh around 8 pounds and up.

Its lightweight makes it even more suitable for smaller-sized dogs, but its redeeming quality of being water-resistant and having the ability to be submerged up to 25 feet in water makes it the best choice for aquatic dogs.

The strap makes adjusting it on your dog’s neck easy, and the remote transmitter can be expanded to command 3 receivers, and thereby 3 dogs.

The tone that comes before the shock conditions the dog to obey commands upon hearing the tone, which later one makes using the shocks obsolete, therefore reducing the amount of time you have to use painful physical experiences on your dog.

Pros:

  • Can be immersed in water up to 25 feet
  • Can be used on 3 separate dogs
  • Includes a manual and DVD for easier-to-follow instructions
  • Has a standard tone (beep) feature
  • Solid battery life

Cons:

  • Stimulation may not be strong enough for more stubborn dogs
  • The range of coverage may not fall short of the alleged 500 yards
  • Battery life isn’t the most solid

The SportDOG FieldTrainer 425 seems a little overpriced for the features has to offer, although it stands out with its 25-feet submerging capabilities, so it would generally be the best choice for an aquatic dog; a golden retriever, for example.

6. Petronics Shock Training Collar – Best Budget Shock Collar

The Petronics Shock Training Collar comes with one transmitter and a collar, but you can buy an additional collar to be controlled by the same transmitter if you want to train two dogs.

Both the collar and remote have rechargeable lithium batteries.

The collar is also water-resistant and receives signals from the distance of 330 yards. These signals include 100 levels of vibration and one standard tone, as well as 100 levels of static shock.

The transmitter’s design is easy to read and ergonomic. It also has an auto-protect mode which ensures that your dog doesn’t suffer too many shocks that may lead to any damage or harm to it.

It saves power with its automatic standby and memory function features. It also helps make your dog visible in low-light or dim-lit circumstances.

Pros:

  • Easy to use
  • The dog collar is fully adjustable
  • Highly affordable

Cons:

  • No lifetime warranty
  • Doesn’t have the widest coverage

At face value, the Petronics Shock Training Collar may not seem like much. It doesn’t have a distinctive feature that makes it stand out from all the other options on the market.

However, it does offer many of the features you’d get on an average collar at a surprisingly low price. It’s one of the cheapest choices you can make that still serves the purpose.

7. Dogtra IQ Remote Trainer – A Fantastic Remote Dog Shock Collar

The Dogtra IQ combines a couple of very useful features such as being 100% waterproof and suitable for smaller dogs that weigh around 10 pounds.

It has a pretty wide coverage range compared to the average collar, which extends up to 400 yards.

It quickly charges as it can be fully charged in around 2 hours. And while its performance is great, it sometimes sends inconsistent stimulations which could mess up your training.

It also works with 100 levels of stimulation, which helps you find the correct range for conditioning your dog, and helps you see progress with very stubborn dogs.

Its receiver comes with a magnetic on/off switch, which facilitates starting and ending the training sessions.

Pros:

  • Absolutely waterproof
  • Wide coverage range
  • Charges quickly (2 hours)
  • Can be used on smaller dogs

Cons:

  • Transmission of stimulations can be subpar
  • Can’t be used on multiple dogs
  • A little pricey

When you consider the fact that many collars can be used on at least 2 dogs at once, the Dogtra IQ falls short of this feature.

However, it combines a couple of features from different other collars, which justifies its above average price tag.

8. Educator E-Collar – A Good Dog Shock Collar for Barking

The Educator E-Collar, unlike many shock collars, can only be used on one dog at a time. This is below average, but regarding the fact that its field of coverage extends up to half a mile, that is quite impressive.

It’s very practical as it can be used on dogs as small as 5 pounds of weight and larger.

It has a small stopwatch transmitter, so it’s small and portable. It either delivers tapping sensations that closely resemble vibrations but can have a little more intensity, so it’s a little more effective.

Its stimulation levels range up to 100 levels, with an extra 60 levels that boost the stimulation. This wide range performs well after only 2 hours to fully charge the battery.

Pros:

  • Charges quickly (2 hours)
  • The transmitter is small and inconspicuous
  • Fits dogs of all sizes
  • Comes with many accessories

Cons:

  • Can only be used on one dog at a time
  • Not much difference between different settings

The Educator E-Collar isn’t the most affordable shock collar on this list, but it has a feature that makes it very exceptional and that is the wide range of stimulation levels.

It does seem a little pricey when you bear in mind that it can only be used on one dog at a time.

9. PetTech Remote Control – Great for Entry-level Users

With a 400-yard signal coverage range, the PetTech shock collar gives your dog more freedom to roam around. Even though it isn’t the widest range, it does come with a lifetime warranty and guarantee that gives users reassurance about the quality and durability of the device.

It’s a very suitable collar for entry-level users and anyone that’s looking to be a trainer as it delivers one-on-one advice concerning how to train your dog.

It includes 4 modes of training stimulations (light, tone, vibration, and static) and a hundred levels for static shocks or vibration modes.

Its battery life is greatly extended thanks to the auto-power protect feature. Its strap is also very adjustable to suit many dog sizes, and the blue backlight provides you with more visibility during any lighting circumstances.

Pros:

  • Lifetime guarantee
  • Suits most dog sizes
  • Solid battery life that is extended with the auto-power protect feature
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Can perform badly from a distance
  • May not work the best on bigger-sized dogs

For a basic, entry-level training collar, the PetTech shock collar is a great choice.

Its price is quite low relative to other options on the list, but saving up –in this collar’s case-, means you will have to compromise some features and get a sub-par performance overall.

10. PetSpy P620 – Best Shock Collar for Large Dogs

The PetSpy P620 is a great shock collar that suits both professional trainers as well as people trying to train a pet dog for the first time.

It helps you stop unwanted behaviors such as excessive barking, aggression, and approaching possibly dangerous objects.

The PetSpy P620 allows you to send signals to your dog’s collar from up to 650 yards away. It includes static shock, vibration, and sound training modes with 16 levels that you can manually adjust.

You can also use a channel switch to rapidly select a dog out of the two you’re training as the transmitter can control up to 2 collars. It has 3 training modes: electric shock, vibration, and beep. It comes with 16 levels that can be adjusted according to different the weight and sensitivity preferences.

The device is 100% waterproof with premium build quality to provide you and your pet with the maximum comfort and durability.

The buttons are conveniently placed and designed in a way that doesn’t require you to look at the device as you use it.

The split cable allows you to charge both the transmitter and receiver simultaneously.

Pros:

  • Works on dogs from 10 to 120 pounds
  • Package includes a lanyard for added convenience
  • A belt clip is also included
  • Lifetime replacement warranty

Cons:

  • Only intensity can be adjusted and not the way shocks are delivered (nick or continuous)
  • Limited range of shock levels

The PetSpy P620 is an excellent shock collar for bigger-sized dogs as it can extend to 120 pounds, whereas the average collar can handle up to 100 pounds only.

It also covers a wider range than the average collar and has an affordable price that isn’t on the higher-end spectrum.

Dog Shock Collar – Buying Guide

What Is a Dog Shock Collar?

A dog shock collar is a training device that can be used to train dogs by discouraging any bad behaviors while promoting proper behaviors. There are three common types:

1) Pet Containment System: This type of shock collar helps keep a dog restricted to a particular area. For example, a pet containment system may be used to maintain a dog in a front yard that doesn’t have a fence. This type of shock collar has become popular over time due to many local laws prohibiting the construction of fences on front yards.

2) Bark Control System: This type of dog shock collar is used to prevent any unnecessary barking by delivering a small shock when the dog starts barking. These collars have been proven to be very effective as dogs tend to quickly realize there is a connection between their barking and the shock.

3) Training Collars / Remote Trainers: The final type of dog shock collars are remotely controlled by the owner attempting to discourage any negative behavioral habits.

The owner can control the intensity of the shock that is delivered to the dog; the idea is to match the intensity of the shock with the severity of the dog’s offenses.

How to Pick The Best Shock Collar for Your Dog?

How to choose the best shock collar for dogs? There are so many different shock collar brands out there that it can be quite difficult to figure out which one would best fit your dog’s needs.

Moreover, it’s also easy to get lost in the intensity levels, ranges, modes, etc.

The most important thing to keep in mind when choosing a good shock collar is the question: will it help eliminate your dog’s negative behaviors?

To make this choosing process less complicated and so you can understand more about shock collars features we have compiled this buying guide. Using this information will help you to make the best choice.

  • Intensity

The intensity of the shock is one of the most important features of shock collars as owners never want to induce excessive discomfort to their dogs.

There are two electrodes that make direct contact with the dog’s skin and even though the stimulation from the shock does not last long this doesn’t mean the dog’s skin can’t get irritated.

This is why it’s important to check what levels of intensity each dog shock collar is capable of. Nowadays most shock collars come equipped with adjustable intensity levels.

When you are looking for shock collars for a dog you want to look for one that many levels of intensity. You do this because having a collar with many levels means that the intensity difference between each level is a lot smaller. Which means you will be less likely to cause your dog any excessive discomfort.

  • Range

The range is all about how far a shock collar and transmitter that can communicate. Note: 1 mile doesn’t mean 1 mile if there are hills, buildings, or other obstructions in the way the range becomes shorter.

When shock collars specify they have a range of 1 mile, this means 1 mile of unobstructed flat land.

The bright side is that nine times out of 10 owners won’t need a large range as they will most likely be using the shock collars in their homes.

Even when training the dog with shock collars extend out to the front or back yard there will never be a need for anything over 500 yards.

  • Audible Mode

When looking for a good shock collar for dogs, you should consider looking for a collar with an audible mode. Most shock collars nowadays give the owners a choice between a shock and an audible option.

This means instead of just a shock owners can choose a warning beep or vibration mode.

Owners are encouraged to use the audible option first to see if there is any change in the dog’s behavior, often this can lead to not needing to shock the dog altogether.

This can a key feature for those who are uneasy about potentially causing excessive discomfort to their dog.

  • Other Features

Waterproof: Dogs like water and tend to play in puddles to cool off after a lot of physical activity which is why it’s a good idea to look for a waterproof shock collar.

Lightweight: If owners plan on using shock collars on their dog’s while they are at the local dog park or while simply going for a walk it’s a good idea to consider how light weight and flexible the collar is.

An important part of the shock collar is having the two electrodes making contact with the dog’s skin; the collar should be flexible enough to make sure there is contact to the skin.

Best Dog Shock Collar Reviews

How does a Shock Collar Work?

Understanding how a dog shock collar works will help you to understand how to use it. They work using static correction. The shock poses no danger to the dog’s health.

It is considered a very mild, harmless electric stimulation that gets the dog’s attention and most shock collars can be adjusted to fine tune the intensity and duration of the shock.

The concept is quite simple; it has to do with positive and negative reinforcements. When a dog is misbehaving the shock collar will send a brief shock to the dogs through two electrodes, this is a negative reinforcement.

When a dog receives this shock, they learn very quickly that a specific behavior and the shock are directly related. The idea is to replace this negative reinforcement with positive reinforcement as the dog stops showing signs of bad behavior. For example, to positively reinforce a dog to continue this good behavior an owner may give them a treat.

Final Words:

There are many options that you can choose from when trying to train your dog, but you have to try your best to keep it humane and only use shocks for extremely necessary situations where your dog might be in real or life-threatening danger.

Your budget can dictate which of the ones on the list you choose, but also your dog’s size makes a difference.

If you have a smaller dog, you should go for the SportDOG FieldTrainer 425, the Educator E-Collar, iPets PET619S.

If you have a bigger dog, opt for the PetSpy P620.

A dog shock collar that seems to fit most requirements and needs is the Garmin Delta XC bundle and the runner-up would be the Dogtra IQ.

Every dog will have different needs. Therefore, there is no one fit all model, one model or other might be a better choice for you.

All of them have high user ratings among various pet owners.

When you are looking at the dog shock collars listed above you want to consider what the purpose of the collar is, are you trying to contain your dog, prevent barking, or simply do some behavioral training.

Also, when you compare them, you should consider your budget and the features you would like the collar you are looking for to have.

Do you want a collar that’s waterproof, what is a sufficient range for your dog, would you like an audible mode?  We hope that with the information that we have provided in this best dog shock collars guide, you will find a shock collar that meets your needs.

Share if you liked it

5 Comments

  1. This collar seems to be faulty as we are getting complaints that they cannot be recharged or the remotes dont always work. It is sold by Yan Liu in from Shenzhen China

    1. Hi,
      Thank you for your comment.
      Which collar do you refer to?

  2. I love the collar and the company is even better. I called them to get a new battery. They couldn’t find me in the system but not only did they still help me out sending me a new transmitter, the guy I talked with sent me a whole new system no questions asked. I don’t know why I wasn’t in the system but he corrected the situation and now my neighbors like us again. lol. I will never use another company.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.