Do you dread walks that should be enjoyable because your dog is dragging or pulling you along? A good dog collar can drastically improve your relationship with your dog!
Walking with your dog doesn’t have to be stressful or strenuous when you have a proper collar that is designed to keep your dog content and controlled. Take a look at the best dog shock collars for training all types of dogs.
Table of Contents
- The Five Best Dog Shock Collars for Training
- Best for Large Dogs: The Dogcare Dog Training Collar With Three Training Modes
- Best for Long-Haired Dogs: The Dog Bark Collar Effective Bark Collar for Dogs
- Best for Small Dogs: The GoodBoy Small Size Remote Collar for Dogs With Beep, Vibration and Shock Modes
- Best for Medium Dogs: The HOLDOG Rechargeable Dog Training Collar With Three Training Modes
- Best for Multiple Dogs: The Bousnic Dog Training Kit With Two Collars
- Dog Shock Collar FAQs
- Are Shock Collars Good for Training Dogs?
- When Should You Start Shock Collar Training?
- Should I Remove My Dog’s Shock Collar at Night?
- Do Dog Shock Collars Hurt Humans?
The Five Best Dog Shock Collars for Training
Note: If you click some of the links in this article we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.
Best for Large Dogs: The Dogcare Dog Training Collar With Three Training Modes
- Features beep, vibration and shock modes.
- A keypad lock prevents accidental shocks.
- Allows you to train multiple dogs with a single remote control.
- Provides a remote range of up to 330 yards.
- Automatically idles after 20 minutes.
- The remote doesn’t always hold the promised 40-day standby time.
- Active-to-shock timing can feel delayed at times.
- Collar is on the bulky side.
The Final Verdict on the Dogcare Dog Training Collar With Three Training Modes
This collar shines due to a long range that allows you to train your dog in a private yard or public park.
The fact that this system includes a remote that allows you to work with up to nine collars at once makes it an economical and practical option if you have multiple dogs.
Best for Long-Haired Dogs: The Dog Bark Collar Effective Bark Collar for Dogs
- A soft, adjustable band fits easily around manes.
- An LED light allows you to see the collar under tufts of fur.
- Sensitivity levels are easily adjusted.
- Warning beeps can be distracting if a dog is playing roughly without barking.
- Sensors can be triggered very easily.
- You must remember to charge the rechargeable battery pretty frequently.
- Not waterproof.
The Final Verdict on the Dog Bark Collar Effective Bark Collar for Dogs
The design of this collar creates a comfortable, secure fit for long-haired dogs. This is a system that’s as easy for the human to use as it is for the dog to wear.
Best for Small Dogs: The GoodBoy Small Size Remote Collar for Dogs With Beep, Vibration and Shock Modes
- Small and lightweight.
- Attractive, sleek style.
- Has a range of more than 900 feet.
- Two collars can be controlled at once.
- Doesn’t hold a charge for more than a few days.
- There’s no way to shorten the length of the longer-than-average shock that is delivered.
- Extremely sensitive.
The Final Verdict on the GoodBoy Small Size Remote Collar for Dogs With Beep, Vibration and Shock Modes
The GoodBoy Small Size Remote Collar for Dogs With Beep, Vibration and Shock Modes is a stylish, smooth-to-the-touch collar that can be used for dogs that are eight pounds and under.
The collar will use only sound or vibration modes when placed on dogs that weigh less than 15 pounds.
Best for Medium Dogs: The HOLDOG Rechargeable Dog Training Collar With Three Training Modes
- Beep, vibration and shock modes.
- Remote range of up to 400 yards.
- Vinyl collar handles moisture nicely.
- A slightly delayed transmission can slow emergency stops.
- Collar is slightly heavier than comparable models.
- Remote’s console can be difficult to read in bright sun.
The Final Verdict on the HOLDOG Rechargeable Dog Training Collar With Three Training Modes
The HOLDOG Rechargeable Dog Training Collar With Three Training Modes is a reliable, easy-to-manage system. The impressive vibrating feature on this collar is effective enough to be the only mode that’s needed for most dog trainers.
Best for Multiple Dogs: The Bousnic Dog Training Kit With Two Collars
- Offers custom shock and vibration levels that can be adjusted for your dog’s temperament.
- Silicone used for the collars is safe and comfortable for skin and coats.
- Range of more than 900 feet.
- Adjusts using a nice clip instead of a buckle.
- Collars don’t stay as tightly adjusted as some others on the market.
- Excess strap material may need to be cut off for smaller dogs.
- It can sometimes seem like the connection between the collars and the controller is intermittent.
The Final Verdict on the Bousnic Dog Training Kit With Two Collars
It’s true that most shock remotes can be used with more than one collar. However, this set brings extra convenience to the table because it actually provides a second collar that integrates seamlessly with your remote.
Dog Shock Collar FAQs
Are Shock Collars Good for Training Dogs?
Shock collars can be helpful when training dogs to remain in certain areas or cease unwanted behaviors. The Humane Society recognizes that shock collars can safely and humanely be used for training.
A study conducted by Dr. Janet Steiss at Auburn University’s College of Veterinary Medicine concluded, “In the present study, with dogs wearing bark control collars intermittently over a 2-week period, the collars effectively deterred barking without statistically significant elevations in plasma cortisol, compared to controls, at any of the time points measured.” Sara Logan Wilson at the Canine Journal is quick to state, “Shock collars are not intended as a punishment, but more as a deterrent to negative or unsafe behavior.”
When Should You Start Shock Collar Training?
It is recommended that a shock collar is introduced only after your dog already understands basic commands for sitting and staying. Delaying usage of a shock collar until a dog already understands basic commands will reduce the likelihood of your dog drawing associations between negative behaviors and the shock sensation. Famed dog trainer Pat Nolan states, “The most effective intensity setting for teaching with the e-collar is one that is just high enough that your dog notices the e-collar, but not so high that he shows any panic or distress.”
Should I Remove My Dog’s Shock Collar at Night?
It is not necessary for a dog to wear a shock collar while sleeping or spending time in a confined portion of your home. Collars should be removed frequently for cleaning purposes. The Humane Society states, “Clean your dog’s neck and the contact points that touch your dog’s neck regularly.”
Do Dog Shock Collars Hurt Humans?
You don’t have to be worried about being injured if you accidentally come into contact with the shock from your dog’s collar. However, a shock collar that is intended for a dog should never be used as a recreational or disciplinary device for humans.